Lab-Created Gemstones vs Natural Gemstones
Shopping for gemstones is something everyone would love as there are immense of types and options of gemstones available but there is one big question: natural or lab-created? Both options have their charm, but they come with differences that matter, especially when you are picking something as personal as jewelry.
Natural gemstones are nature’s art, formed deep within the Earth over millions of years. Lab-created gems, on the other hand, offer a modern twist, with the same sparkle and durability but made in a fraction of the time.
This post will make it simple. We’ll walk you through what sets these two apart so you can pick the gemstone that fits your style, budget, and values perfectly.
What is a Natural Gemstone?
A natural gemstone is a mineral or organic material formed beneath the Earth’s surface through natural processes. These stones are created over thousands or even millions of years, shaped by heat, pressure, and geological activity.
Because they are mined from the Earth, each natural gemstone is truly unique. The color, clarity, and tiny imperfections—known as inclusions—tell a story of where and how the stone was formed. These quirks give natural gemstones their charm and make them highly sought after by collectors and jewelry lovers.
From diamonds and emeralds to sapphires and rubies, natural gemstones are selected for their rarity and natural beauty, making them a timeless choice for unique jewelry.
Explore Gem Jewelers Co.’s gemstone jewelry collection to choose stunning pieces featuring these precious stones.
What is a Lab-Grown Gemstone?
A lab-grown gemstone is a stone created in a controlled laboratory setting using advanced technology that mimics the natural processes of gem formation. These gems have the same physical, chemical, and optical properties as natural gemstones, the difference is they are just made much faster.
Unlike natural stones, which form over millions of years in the Earth, lab-grown gems are produced in a matter of weeks or months. Because they are made in a lab, these stones are often flawless, without the inclusions or imperfections found in natural gems.
Lab-grown gemstones are growing in popularity because they are more affordable and considered an ethical choice, as they don’t involve mining. These can be considered as a modern alternative with all the beauty of traditional gemstones.
These unnatural gemstones are made through HPHT and CVD methods:
1. High Pressure Technique (HPHT)
The HPHT method replicates the natural conditions under which diamonds and other gemstones form deep within the Earth.
A tiny seed crystal is subjected to extreme pressure and high temperatures (around 1,500°C), causing carbon atoms to crystallize around it. This process creates high-quality lab-grown diamonds and gemstones in weeks.
2. Controlled Environment (CVD)
CVD Method uses a controlled environment where carbon-rich gases, like methane, are heated in a vacuum chamber. The gases break down, and carbon atoms crystallize on a substrate, growing a gemstone layer by layer.
This method allows precise control over clarity and quality, efficiently producing lab-grown diamonds and other gemstones.
Quick Comparison of the Natural and Lab-Created Stones
| Aspect | Natural Gemstone | Lab-Created Gemstone |
| Formation Process | The formulation process takes millions of years naturally under extreme heat and pressure inside the earth. | It is made in labs using high-tech methods replicating natural conditions in a few weeks. |
| Price | Natural gemstones are more expensive because they are rare and take time. | It is more affordable because quickly produced and doesn't require mining. |
| Quality and Appearance | Each stone is unique, with natural imperfections and inclusions due to durability and neatness. | There are often fewer inclusions, and they can be made to look flawless, but they still have the same quality and appearance. |
| Environmental Impact | Mining can cause environmental harm due to deforestation and soil erosion during the making process. | They are more Eco-friendly, as they dont require mining, have a smaller environment, and take minimum time in production. |
| Inclusions and Purity | Natural gemstones have a natural inclusion and purity, which makes each gemstone unique. | They have fewer inclusions and are often purer because they are made under controlled conditions. |
| Resale Value | Natural gemstones tend to hold value and can be resale. | Usually, they have lower resale value due to their easy production. |
| Ethical Consideration | Natural gemstones have some sources of natural gems that may be linked to unethical practices during formation. | They are considered more ethical due to their easy formation; they are dont in mining. |
How Do Natural Gemstones Differ from Lab-Created Gemstones?
iStock/SergiiZyskо
Understanding the differences between natural and lab-created gemstones can make your decision easier. Here's a detailed comparison to help you choose the right one based on history, cost, ethics, rarity, and personal values.
1. History of Natural and Lab-created Gemstones
Natural Gemstones are formed deep within the Earth over millions of years. Each stone reflects a natural process shaped by heat, pressure, and time, making it one-of-a-kind.
Their history gives them a sense of mystique and authenticity that is hard to replicate.
Lab-Created Gemstones, on the other hand, are crafted in controlled environments. Advanced technology replicates the conditions that create natural stones but speeds up the process to just weeks or months.
While they lack the geological history of natural stones, lab-grown gems still share the same chemical and physical properties.
2. Price Differences in Lab Created and Natural Gemstones
Natural Gemstones are typically more expensive due to their rarity, the lengthy formation process, and the resources required for mining. These stones are treasures of the Earth, and their limited availability often drives up their price.
Lab-Grown Gemstones are more budget-friendly. Since they’re produced in labs without mining, they’re easier and more efficient to manufacture.
This makes them a more affordable choice for those who want high-quality gemstones without paying a premium for rarity.
3. Ethical Impact: Mining Concerns vs. Sustainability
Natural Gemstones can sometimes come with ethical concerns. Mining operations in some regions have been linked to environmental degradation, unsafe labor conditions, and even conflict—giving rise to terms like “blood diamonds” or “conflict minerals.”
Lab-Created Gemstones are considered a more ethical option and all for the good reasons. Their production doesn’t involve mining, which reduces the environmental footprint and eliminates concerns about exploitative practices.
For buyers who value sustainability and fair practices, lab-grown gems offer peace of mind.
4. Rarity and Availability of Gemstones
Natural Gemstones are rare, with their availability dependent on geological conditions and mining operations. This rarity adds to their allure and makes them highly desirable for collectors and jewelry enthusiasts.
Lab-created gemstones are far more accessible. Since they can be produced in virtually unlimited quantities, they are readily available in the market. This accessibility makes them a practical choice for those who prioritize affordability and convenience.
5. Personal Choice: What Matters Most to You
In the end all the matter between natural and lab-created gemstones ultimately comes down to what you value.
Natural Gemstones appeal to those who appreciate their history, rarity, and the natural imperfections that make them unique.
Lab-created gemstones are perfect for anyone seeking affordability, ethical sourcing, and modern production methods.
Both types are beautiful and durable, offering their own advantages.
FAQs
Do lab-created diamonds have a shorter lifespan than natural diamonds?
No, a lab-grown diamond is chemically equivalent to a natural diamond, meaning it lasts as long and has the same strength and hardness.
Can a lab-created diamond be considered as valuable as a natural diamond in a wedding or anniversary gift?
While lab-created diamonds are excellent in quality and beauty, natural diamonds often have greater emotional and historical value, especially those for milestone gifts such as wedding rings or anniversary presents.
How can I distinguish between a lab-created gemstone and a natural gemstone?
You can distinguish a lab-created gemstone from a natural one by examining inclusions or imperfections—natural stones often have unique flaws, while lab-grown gems are usually flawless. A jeweler or gemologist can also use specialized tools to confirm the difference.
Final Verdict: Lab-Grown vs Natural Gemstones
When it comes to choosing between natural and lab-created gemstones, it’s really about what matters most to you. Do you love the history and uniqueness of something formed by the Earth over millions of years? Or are you more into the sustainability and budget-friendly perks of a lab-grown gem?
Natural gemstones carry the charm of rarity and a story written by the Earth over millions of years, while lab-grown gems offer an ethical, affordable, and equally stunning alternative.
No option is inherently better than the other—it’s all about finding a gemstone that aligns with your values and reflects your personal style.
Leave a comment